PCE Inflation Stuck at 3.7% as Consumer Spending Stalls, September Rate Hike Odds Jump
The Fed's preferred inflation gauge held steady in July while real spending barely moved, pushing markets to price in 40% odds of another rate increase.
Personal consumption expenditures inflation stayed stubbornly stuck at 3.7 percent in July as real consumer spending stalled, according to the Commerce Department's latest report released Friday. The data showed Americans pulled back on discretionary purchases while the Federal Reserve's preferred inflation gauge refused to budge from the elevated level it has maintained for three consecutive months.
The PCE price index, which the Fed watches more closely than the Consumer Price Index, held at 3.7 percent year-over-year in July, matching June and May readings. Core PCE, which strips out volatile food and energy prices, ticked down slightly to 3.4 percent from 3.5 percent in June, but remained well above the Fed's 2 percent target.
The inflation persistence comes as consumer spending growth effectively stalled. Real personal consumption expenditures increased just 0.1 percent in July after June's 0.4 percent gain, suggesting households are feeling the cumulative pressure of higher prices and borrowing costs. Nominal spending rose 0.5 percent, meaning nearly all the increase went to inflation rather than buying more goods and services.
September Rate Hike Odds Climb to 40 Percent
Financial markets reacted to the mixed signals by increasing the probability of another Federal Reserve rate hike at the September 16-17 meeting. Fed funds futures now price in 40 percent odds of a quarter-point increase, up from 28 percent before Friday's data release.
The Fed held rates steady at its July meeting after hiking by a quarter point in June, but Chairman Kevin Warsh warned at the Jackson Hole Economic Symposium in late August that policymakers still have quote work to do if inflation readings don't improve. Friday's PCE report suggests that work remains unfinished despite the prior rate increases.
Bond markets reflected the shifting expectations as Treasury yields climbed across the curve. The 10-year note rose to 5.01 percent, its highest level since 2007, while the 2-year yield touched 4.87 percent. Rising yields signal investor anticipation that rates will stay higher for longer as the Fed maintains its inflation-fighting posture.
The Spending Slowdown That Wasn't Enough
The stall in real consumer spending suggests the Fed's prior rate hikes are finally crimping household budgets, but not quickly enough to bring inflation back to target. Personal income grew 0.3 percent in July while disposable income rose 0.4 percent, but consumers saved most of that gain rather than spending it.
The personal saving rate jumped to 4.5 percent in July from 4.3 percent in June, marking the highest level since February. Americans are banking more of each paycheck as uncertainty about the economic outlook and persistent inflation pressure budgets. Credit card balances remain elevated at record highs while delinquency rates have climbed back to pre-pandemic levels.
Services inflation drove most of the PCE persistence, with housing costs, healthcare, and recreation prices all posting gains. Goods prices actually declined 0.2 percent for the month, reflecting softer demand for durable items like appliances and electronics. But services make up roughly 60 percent of the PCE basket, and those prices have proven far stickier than the Fed anticipated.
Labor Market Strength Complicates Fed's Path
The PCE report arrived one week after the August jobs report showed employers added 162,000 positions, slightly above forecasts but with wage growth still lagging inflation. Average hourly earnings rose 4.3 percent year-over-year, which sounds robust until compared to the 3.7 percent PCE inflation rate. Real wages remain under pressure, explaining why consumers are pulling back on spending despite nominal income gains.
The labor market's continued strength gives the Fed room to keep tightening if inflation persists, but also raises concerns about whether higher rates are actually cooling demand. Unemployment held at 4.2 percent in August, near historic lows, while job openings remain elevated at 8.9 million open positions.
Some economists argue the Fed's focus on services inflation misses the broader economic slowdown underway. Manufacturing activity contracted for a fourth straight month in August, housing starts fell 11 percent in July, and consumer confidence surveys show growing pessimism about the economy's direction. But Fed officials have insisted they need to see sustained improvement in inflation data, not just economic weakness.
What September's Fed Meeting Could Bring
The September 16-17 Federal Open Market Committee meeting will give policymakers their first chance to respond to the PCE data alongside August inflation reports due next week. The consensus forecast calls for the Fed to hold rates steady at the current 3.50-3.75 percent target range, but the lack of progress on inflation keeps another hike firmly in play.
Fed Chairman Warsh has emphasized the central bank's data-dependent approach, meaning officials will assess each new economic report before committing to a policy path. The August CPI and PPI readings, due September 13 and 14 respectively, will provide critical context for the Fed's deliberations. If those reports show inflation reaccelerating, the case for a September hike strengthens considerably.
The Fed's September economic projections will also reveal where policymakers see rates heading through year-end and into 2027. The June projections showed most officials expecting rates to peak near 4 percent before declining next year, but persistent inflation could force an upward revision in those forecasts.
Consumers Face Another Month of Budget Pressure
For American households, the PCE report confirms what many already feel: prices remain uncomfortably high even as spending growth slows. Gasoline prices have climbed back above $4 per gallon nationally while grocery bills stay elevated despite some moderation in food inflation. Rent increases show no signs of cooling as housing supply remains constrained.
The September rate hike debate will unfold over the next two weeks as the Fed weighs competing signals. Inflation isn't accelerating, but it isn't declining fast enough either. Consumer spending is slowing, but the labor market remains tight. The economy avoids recession, but growth momentum has clearly faded.
Financial markets will watch the August inflation data and the Fed's September decision with heightened attention. The 40 percent probability of a rate hike reflects genuine uncertainty about what Powell and his colleagues will do. The PCE report kept that question wide open, extending the inflation fight into at least one more Fed meeting and possibly beyond.